Amethyst Geode Utah

Get Top Products With Fast and Free Shipping on eBay. Looking For Great Deals? We Have Almost Everything on eBay The amethyst crystals, ranging up to 1 inch in length, display excellent crystal form in various shades of purple. The small size of the bixbyite and rutile is more than compensated for by the excellent crystal forms of these relatively rare minerals Yes, there are five locations in Utah where Amethyst has been found and is still available for the rock hound to collect. You won't find the large towers of Crystal Amethyst you see in stores and at Rock and Gem shows. Those specimens mostly come from South America and Madagascar. But you can find smaller crystals in pale colors Rockhounding Utah for Geodes, Fossils and More!. Utah is a state practically made of rock. The vast lands of southern Utah are intricately carved into the red and white sandstone limestone layers of the Colorado Plateau, leaving behind well-known monuments in locations like Canyonlands and Zion National Parks. However, there is plenty of other rocks and minerals aside from the red sandstone of. Dugway Geode Beds. The Dugway Geode Beds are a Rockhounding hotspot. The most common mineral found within the geodes is quartz in various colors: clear (rock crystal), purple (amethyst), and pink (rose). Geodes are usually found below the ground surface. The best place to look for geodes is in areas that have been previously excavated

Great Offers - Great Prices On Top Item

The result is geodes with spherical shapes and crystal-lined cavities. Roughly 32,000 to 14,000 thousand years ago, a large body of water known as Lake Bonneville covered most of western Utah. The lake's wave activity eroded the geode-bearing rhyolite and redeposited the geodes several miles away in the Dugway geode bed area as lake sediments Wendover Amethyst. One of the rumored spots to dig amethyst in Utah is actually just over the border in Nevada outside Wendover. You will be hard rock digging to find any purple as this habit of amethyst is not UV stable and fades in sunlight. There is plenty on the surface though of the clear and white remains The quartz might be clear, purple (a.k.a. amethyst) or pink. If you can wait til you get home to open your geodes, you can cut them open using a power saw with a carbide-tipped blade. This gives your geode a more clean cut, and you can polish the cut edges to make a pretty keepsake

Boulder Amethyst is a home based amethyst rock shop located in Superior, Colorado, 5 minutes from Flat Irons Mall. (A few minutes from Louisville, Broomfield, Boulder and Arvada, and 20 minutes or so from much of the Denver area. Call or text for the address and to set up a time to stop by the Boulder Amethyst home based rock shop The Dugway Geode Beds location includes a private claim owned by the Crapo family based out of Delta, Utah. They manage a rock shop in their backyard called the Bug House in addition to overseeing the Dugway Geode Beds claim as well as the the U-Dig trilobite claim further West of Delta. Although you can dig for geodes outside of the. Looking at an amethyst geode for example, the deeper the purple color, the higher the quality. Some of the best (and largest) amethyst geodes can be found within volcanic rocks in Minas Gerais, which is a state in Southeastern Brazil. States that are specifically known for their high geode density are Arizona, Utah, Nevada and California. The Dugway Geode Beds are one of the most popular mineral hunting areas in Utah. Here you can dig for large geodes that most often contain clear quartz, amethyst, or rose quartz crystals. These geodes formed when hot gasses bubbled up and were trapped inside a bubble, creating beautiful crystal formations

Amazing Amethyst Geode Display On Stand - Museum Piece For

Raw Amethyst, Cathedral Amethyst, Geode Cluster, perfect for anxiety relief. DeepPurpleProject. 5 out of 5 stars. (801) $39.00 FREE shipping. Bestseller. Add to Favorites LotCow 5 Pcs Natural Amethyst Crystal Quartz Amethyst Cluster Large Rough Ore Druzy Geode Gemstone Sculpture Geodes with Crystals Break Your Own Decoration (0.16-0.22lb) 4.0 out of 5 stars 1 $10.99 $ 10 . 9 Utah Amethyst Jasper Geode. Condition is New. Shipped with USPS First Class Package. US buyers only. See photos for size. Nice collector's piece! Seller assumes all responsibility for this listing. Shipping and handling. This item will ship to United States, but the seller has not specified shipping options

A direct-from-the-source provider of quality geode and mineral specimens since 1995, Geode Gallery LLC is based in Davenport, Iowa and is managed by Mike Sandstrom, who collected his first geode at the age of 8.Today, Mike maintains the Geode Gallery website, travels to rock, gem, and mineral shows across the country, and is in his 24th year of actively mining Keokuk geodes, the Geode Gallery. 159 Items ($1 to $17,950) 53.5 Massive, Amethyst Geode Pair With Exceptional Color - Uruguay. $17,950. 14.5 Deep Purple Amethyst Crystal Cluster - Congo. $2,495. 12.5 Deep Purple Amethyst Crystal Cluster - Congo. $1,995. 12.6 Amethyst Geode Section on Metal Stand - Deep Purple Crystals. $1,895 Geodes are given a variety of names. The word geode is often preceded by the name of the mineral material which has filled the geode. Agate geode and amethyst geode are examples. The word geode might also be preceded by a geographic or stratigraphic name. Keokuk geode and Brazilian geode are examples

The Rockhounder: Bixbyite, Rutile, and Amethyst Crystals

  1. Utah Rock Hounding. Utah is known by some as the Rock Hounding Capital of the United States! Destinations throughout Central Utah provide the most diverse and unique rock hounding sites in the state. Popular finds include trilobites, gem quality topaz, red beryl, geodes and sun stones
  2. Rockhounding in Wendover is always a treat. It was a nice windy cold day but the company was fantastic. The Mexican place went out of business and it was re..
  3. ing operations have been taking place for about 100 years. Although tours are offered, they have been, hopefully just temporarily, suspended during the present COVID-19 crisis. The
  4. The Dugway geode beds in Western Utah. The Warsaw Formation in the Keokuk region near the area where Missouri, Iowa, and Illinois. The volcanic rock deposits in Southern Brazil and Uruguay which produce gorgeous and sometimes very large amethyst geodes
  5. Open full screen to view more. This map was created by a user. Learn how to create your own
  6. erals, or more than one

Amethyst in Utah - Where? Utah Gemstone Jeweler

Where To Find Geodes In Utah (Plus Fossils and Much More

Some of the states where they're widely located are Ohio, Missouri, Utah, Iowa, Kentucky, and Indiana. In the early twentieth century, a large geode, known as Crystal Cave, was discovered in Put-in-Bay, Ohio, which is open for tourists during the summer. Geodes are also common in other countries like Brazil, Mexico, Spain, and Namibia Jan 13, 2014 - Explore Barbara Hardenbrook's board Dugway Geodes on Pinterest. See more ideas about dugway, geode, rocks and minerals Bureau of Land Management, Utah. The Dugway Geode Beds are a Rockhounding hotspot. The most common mineral found within the geodes is quartz in various colors: clear (rock crystal), purple (amethyst), and pink (rose). Geodes are usually found below the ground surface. The best place to look for. Utah topaz is a highly prized mineral and worth the effort to dig for. Quartz Geodes . If you visit the Dugway Geode Beds in Juab County you're sure to find some of the stones. These geodes are typically hollow and lined with massive banded quartz. Among the varieties found here are rock crystal, rose quartz, and even amethyst

Earn up to 19 Points. These Ultimate Peace Vera Cruz Amethyst Geodes are here to fill you and your space with their incredibly serene energy. Vera Cruz amethyst is THE clearest and highest vibrational form of amethyst on Earth. Working with it can activate the pineal gland or Seat of the Soul, the place of inner knowing The Rock Warehouse is a wholesale supplier of gem and mineral products such as geodes, amethyst, bookends, tumbled stones, polished rock and mineral products, mineral specimens, fossils, gemstone gifts and jewelry, Pakistani onyx, gemstone decorator products such as clocks, lamps, candleholders Volcanic areas are a common place to find geodes. In the United States they can be found in California, Arizona, Utah, Nevada, Illinois, Missouri, Kentucky, and Iowa. In fact, the geode is Iowa's state rock. You can buy a small 2-inch geode for a couple of dollars. Large geodes with amethyst crystals can be worth $1,000 phone: 1-800-569-4648 or 1-928-565-2882. mail: PO BOX 6975 Kingman, AZ 86402. Showroom: 4107 Hwy 68, Golden Valley, AZ 86413. ArizonaRockShops specializes in Brazilian products including amethyst, agate book-ends, quartz crystals, gemstones, rough and finished mineral specimens, carvings, agate ends, small and large decorator pieces, and. Felch Creek: Felch Creek will provide you with agate, geodes, and jasper. It is one of the few locations where true botryoidal fluorite specimens can be found. This stream is close to Oil Well Flats. Houselog Creek: Houselog Creek is located in Saguache County at a distance of 12 miles from Saguache. Houselog Creek usually offers its diggers.

Dugway Geode Beds Bureau of Land Managemen

  1. eralization—the process when
  2. AD-145 Amethyst and Chalcedony geode $50 Dugway Mountains District, Dugway Range, Tooele County, UT 10.1 x 7.3 x 2.6 c
  3. Trina's Rock Shop - Full Service Lapidary Store. View our Shop. Read More. Services. Rock/Geode Cutting, Polishing, Cabochon Cutting, Custom Jewelry. Read More. Custom Work. Wire Woven Chrysocolla Tenorite in Copper Pendants. Read More
  4. Petrified Wood, Geodes, Crystals, Agates and Carvings. PR500b This is a very cool larger, very pretty Brazilian Agate slab. The agate slab has fantastic banding in shades of blue and grey with various other accents and neat and unusual Dendrites. The irregular shaped slab measures 13 1/4 wide x 10 5/8 x 1 thick and weighs over 9 1/2 pounds

Video: The Rockhounder: Dugway Geode Beds, Juab County - Utah

We are 2 moms who have a passion for creativity, making bath time fun, and promoting the importance of self care. We are obsessed with using fewer, better, more expensive, & luxurious ingredients to make amazing products that are rarely seen on the market ⚒Amethyst Geode ⚒ Drusy Quartz Agate Amethyst Geode to be exact, from Dugway, Utah. These are super hard to find in this condition! Good luck to whoever finds one this Saturday! Utah Rockhounding. 7.9K views · June 13, 2019. 0:50. Our Group did great today with athe new Rainbow Drusy Quartz pocket. We all scored nicely today

BLOW YOUR MIND Huge Amethyst Geode Uruguay 74.00 High Quality Crystal Custom Stand PK-1 Sale price $ 47,999 99 $ 47,999.99 Regular price $ 60,000 00 $ 60,000.00 Save $ 12,000.01 Close (esc Geode banding and coloration is the result of variable impurities. Iron oxides will impart rust hues to siliceous solutions. Most geodes contain clear quartz crystals, while others have purple amethyst crystals. Still others can have agate, chalcedony, or jasper banding or crystals such as calcite, dolomite, celestite, etc All Geodes Are Not Created Equal The first one is quite hollow but for a nice layer of medium-sized blue crystals. These dugway geodes have bands of blue and pink. The geode at the left and the one at the top of the page are both dugways from Utah. The colors come from the different minerals that flowed through the bubble so many millions of years ago DUGWAY GEODES Juab County, Utah These unusual single and multi-cavity geodes are Utah's version of Thunder Eggs. Within a rhyolite exterior shell, druzy and crystalline quartz-lined cavities were formed by silica-rich fluids seeping into cavities formed in the rhyolite. This piece has a cut base with felt on the base

February's Birthstone People love Amethyst from Uruguay because most pieces tend to have a darker and richer purple than those pieces from Brazil. The main drawback is that most pieces from Uruguay tend to have small crystals whereas Brazil pieces can have fairly large crystals. This specime There are geodes throughout the world, but they are most commonly located in deserts, volcanic ash beds, and areas rich in limestone. It is also common to find them in lake and river beds. If you are located in the USA, you will probably have particular luck in the southwest in states like California, Arizona, Utah, and Nevada Beautiful Amethyst Cathedrals (5 to 5') up to 65% off - Request pictures as inventory too large for whole sale. 1000 rocks and fossils for only $5 each. Specials . Forms of payment: Cash, Credit Card ++ Not on invitation to future events yet: Send email subject invite me - your city, include your city - Rocktrading (at) aol . co


Wendover Amethyst - Rockhounds Anonymou

Every geode is unique, just as every snowflake is unique. The combination of patterns, colors, and orientation of the crystals is different in every geode.The largest amethyst geode in the world is called the Empress of Uruguay. It's over eleven feet tall and weighs nearly 5000 pounds Amethyst is the world's most popular purple gem. It is the purple color variety of quartz that has been used in personal adornment for over 2000 years. Amethyst is the birthstone of February and an important New Age gem. It is used to produce faceted stones, cabochons, beads, tumbled stones, and many other items for jewelry and ornamental use Geodes are said to be rock structures whose shape can be anything between spherical and subspherical. The unique thing about them is that the internal cavity of these rocks is lined with minerals. They have a very durable surface that protects them against weathering. In other words, it means that the outer mineral layer of the geodes is stronger and more durable than the host rock Huge Gem Amethyst Rock Fossil Sale Houston March 2nd, 3rd (9am - 5pm) - (Houston, TX) Sale date and times: Saturday March 2nd - 9am - 5pm Sunday March 3rd - 9am - 5pm Admission = Free Parking = Free Free garnet $8 value for the first 1000 visitors / limit 1 Meteorites $10 each/ Continue reading Gem, Amethyst, Rock, Fossil Sale Houston March 2-3, 201 Oct 28, 2020 - Explore Karen Yong's board Rock hounding utah on Pinterest. See more ideas about rock hounding utah, rock hounding, utah

Gem Hunting in South Dakota. Rose quartz and agate are the gemstones to hunt for in South Dakota. Large deposits of rose quartz can be found in Custer County. Agates can be found throughout the state, but the prized Fairburn agate, the state's gemstone, can only be found near Fairburn, in the Black Hills area Shop Beautiful Amethyst Geode with Display Stand - AWS0165 at the lowest price from Southern Minerals . Premium Quality Uruguayan Minerals. Wholesale - Retail. Worldwide shipping. Buy now or write us for a wholesale quote 4.9 Calcite Crystal Filled Septarian Geode Egg - Utah (Item #176038), Septarian Geodes for sale. FossilEra your source to quality fossil specimens

Sparkling Microcrystalline Quartz Dugway Geode – Rockology

Dugway Geode Beds: A Great Place To Dig For Geodes In Uta

Amethyst Spheres, Amethyst Geodes, Amethyst Crystals & An Amethyst Pond ; Agate Geodes. Druzy Geodes. Amethyst Geodes. $0 - $50. $50 - $100. $100 - $500. $500 - $9,999,999. $15. 295CTS BRAZIL GEODES MS 945. Mygems. $15 $15 . $22. 10.67 CTS GEODE PAIR ZACATECAS MEXICO-POLISHED [MGW5525]. This is a gorgeous, dark purple amethyst geode section from the mines near Artigas, Uruguay. Really nice color in this specimen and part of the outer rind is polished. While Brazil to the north is a much more prolific producer of amethyst , the amethyst mined near Artigas, Uruguay tends to be much darker with higher quality crystals Amethyst. Part of this specimen is the usual hematite-included red amethyst typical of the Thunder Bay region in Ontario, Canada - the remainder is the new starburst variety found only in the Current River district. Thanks to Marty Lewadny at CrystalEnthusia (formerly Crystal Variations) for the specimen and the image Geodes are found throughout the world, but the most concentrated areas are located in the deserts. Volcanic ash beds, or regions containing limestone, are common geode locations. There are many easily accessible geode collecting sites in the western United States, including in California, Arizona, Utah and Nevada

CUSTER - Clear quartz, amethyst and citrine are found. Large geodes are common. Banded, red and yellow agate is scattered over the area. A forest of petrified wood is near Challis. Near the East Fork of the Salmon River is an excellent collecting locality where a variety of cryptocrystalline quartz is found in blood red sandstone. Near. A crystal cluster is one of the best healing crystals to have in your home, office and sacred space. A crystal cluster formations have many different crystal points embedded into one base; the points very in size (large or small). Crystal clusters radiate immense amounts of energy due to the multiple crystal points, filling the surrounding space with light and positive energy. These healing. Accent crystals are perfect for any room, tabletop, shelf, and meditation space. Big quartz points, large amethyst geodes, illuminated crystal light boxes, and mineral sculptures. They are an ideal accessory size for interior designers. Free Domestic USPS Priority Shipping on Orders $50 and up (excludes oversized items Geodes are common in some formations in the United States (mainly in Indiana, Iowa, Missouri, western Illinois, Kentucky, and Utah).They also are common in Brazil, Namibia, and Mexico. Geodes are also abundant in the Mendip Hills in Somerset, England, where they are known locally as potato stones.. Vugs and crystal caves. In 2000, a team of geologists discovered a cave filled with giant.

Boulder Amethyst - Amethyst Geodes, Cathedrals and Display

Took the kids out rock hounding today, looking for zeolites, quartz crystals, Amethyst, and found some citrine too. The new Westside road interchange off hi.. Arizona Amethyst Mine Hiking Trips are for those who want to add a sense of adventure to the experience. These are for expert hikers and take at least 6 to 8 hours. The tour includes water, juices, Arizona teas, fresh fruit, nuts and snack bars. The cost is $1000 for up to 5 people plus $100 per person mine entrance fee

Topaz Mountain - Rockhounding Utah

1.4 Sparkly, Pink Amethyst Geode Section - Argentina This is a beautiful find out of Argentina, featuring true pink amethyst crystals from the Choique Mine. It occurs in geodic formations or cavities lined with crystals Stop in one or two and pick up a geode from Dugway, Utah or some local trilobite fossils. If you're into the usual rose quartz, citrine, kyanite and amethyst, you'll find plenty of that too. And gigantic pieces of blue/turquoise glass. It's pretty. And shiny. And you'll want some. So will grandma Add Event to Calendar 2021-07-11 09:00:00 2021-07-11 17:00:00 America/Chicago Gem Amethyst Rock Fossil Sale One Day Only July 11 Hampton Inn, 11271 Reiger Road, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, United States, 70809 Gem Amethyst Rock Fossil Sale One Day Only July 11 event on Helm Ticket Jackson's Crossroads Amethyst Mine has become one of the best known operating Amethyst mines in the world. Single crystals or clusters, matrix specimens, and faceted stones from this locale can display some unique qualities of color and growth patterns. Ranging from light violet to deep purple with blue and red color shifts, this fairly new. Geodes may contain quartz crystals and are quite intricate and beautiful. Topaz Mountain Area. Types of rocks/minerals: Topaz, red beryl, bixbyite, pseudobrookite, hematite, garnet, chalcedony, amethyst, flourite, calcite, cassiterite, durangite. Location: Roughly 38 miles west of Utah Highway

Dugway Geode Beds - Rockhounding Uta

These Peaceful Sleep Amethyst Geode Generators are truly magical, jaw-dropping towers of peace, tranquility, and ethereal magic New! amethyst statues reasonable, high quality! $7.50 and up. Amethyst geodes. Onyx Vases. Turquoise nuggets...mine direct! Carved/polished turquoise beads. Exotic turquoise necklaces. Citrine Geodes Rockology is the premiere online provider of gem show quality amethyst, agate and other gem and mineral specimens - all available for wholesale and retail. Other specialty materials include: Geodes, Arizona Splash Copper, Hearts, Holiday and Special Occasion Gifts, Jewelry, and Interior Design Decorations Amethyst Geode. Was $895.00 NOW $626.00 Save $269.00 (30%. Available for purchase in-store only. Store Hours Mon - Fri Noon - 7pm Sat 11am - 7pm Sun Noon - 6. Meet Heather Barrett. Heather is an Ordained Minister & Reiki Master. She offers classes in Beading, Beginning to Meditate, Beginning to Use Stones & Crystals, Advanced Stones & Crystals. Utah- Geodes have been found in the Dugway Geode Beds in Juab County, in the Caineville Wash, and off the San Rafael Swell in Emry and Wayne Counties (Southeast Utah). Vermont- No references found. Virginia- No references found. Washington- Geodes have been found at Walker Valley Geode Site, around Ceres Hill and Lucas Creek in Lewis County


Where Can You Find Geodes? They Might Be Closer Than You

Several varieties come from Indonesia, Utah and Arizona. Sometimes, it can be confused with lavender botryoidal smithsonite, which is much softer (Mohs 4-5). Amethyst Sage chalcedony, from northern Nevada, is a translucent lavender chalcedony with black and brown, dendtritic inclusions of manganese Photo Gallery Archives. Johnnie and Norma Kennedy Richardson, the mind and heart of our family, ranch and of course the rock business. We carry on as they had, trying to provide a fun, informative day with beauty of the rough and finished rock at our rock shop. Johnnie and Norma Kennedy Richardson. Polished Thunderegg Halves Directions to North of Wendover Agate: From the intersection of 800 North and I-15 in Orem, Utah. 1. Drive North on I-15 for 36 miles until the exit for I-80 Westbound. 2. Drive on Westbound I-80 for 115 miles to exit 4 (The only thing at this exit is a gas station and the entrance to the Salt Flats) 3 This one has a druzy quartz geode center as an added bonus. A striking double geode with a little bit of white lining to emphasize the quartz crystal cavities. A nice little amethyst head pops out! In the heat of afternoon, a group of deer move in and lay down in the pits, seeking the coolness of the shade and the shadowed soil Shop Minerals. Fossils. Shop Fossils. Direct importer, wholesale distributor of minerals, fossils, and jewelry, selling wholesale to the trade for over 40 years. Wholesale Mineral Supplier. Shop Minerals. Fossils. Shop Fossils. NOTICE-JUNE 22, 2021 Orders are taking 7-10 business days to process

Rare Gems, Minerals, and Fossils in Utah - Digging Location

AD-145 Amethyst & Chalcedony geode $50. Dugway Mountains District, Dugway Range, Tooele County, UT. 10.1 x 7.3 x 2.6 cm. This is one of the more colorful Dugway geodes that I have come across in my 30+ years of collecting Amethyst is a semiprecious stone and is the traditional birthstone for February. Amethyst is a violet variety of quartz whose primary hues from a light pinkish violet to a deep purple are often used in jewelry. The color of amethyst is caused by iron impurities in the crystal Touring Crystal Cave, the World's Largest Geode. You'll learn about the history of the cave, how workers discovered the cave in 1887 while digging a well beneath the winery and how tours of Crystal Cave single-handedly saved the winery during Prohibition. The original cave was much smaller than what you see today

The amethyst found here is apparently very light sensitive and not usually used for making jewelry. The hues of the crystal vary from violet to sometimes colorless. Another site in southern California where amethyst has been found is the Hauser Geode Beds located close to the town of Blythe. A pale pinkish violet color of the crystal is found here Enjoy our displays of other stones unique to Utah and Arizona, such as Geodes, Septarian, Selinite and Petrified Wood. We have Onyx, Jasper, Amethyst, Quartz Crystals and more. We have bookends in over 10 different stones, in a variety of sizes Though geodes may look like ordinary rocks, they conceal a hollowed interior that is chock full of different colored minerals and rocks such as amethyst, quartz, agate, and jade. Geodes form naturally over time as a result of specific geological processes and can be found in Mexico and many regions of the United States, such as the Southwest. Geodes to Break Open in Your Store! We sell some of the best break open geodes in the World. Starting with the Incredible Coconut Geode direct from our Geode Mine! Learn more. Las Choyas Coconut Whole Geodes 95% Hollow. From $9.95. In stock, 883 units. Chihuahua Trancas Geodes 95% Hollow. From $4.95 Geodes can be found anywhere in the world and are most commonly located in deserts, volcanic ash beds or regions containing limestone. In the United States, geodes are commonly found in California, Utah and Arizona, and the geode is the state rock of Iowa. Locate an area where you are allowed to dig your own geodes

FindingRocksFindingRocksHow to Identify an Unopened Geode: 5 Steps (with Pictures)

This septarian cube from Utah weighs 1078 grams and measures 7.7 x 8 x 8 cm. Septerian is a combination of aragonite, calcite, and limestone. These thulite earings from Norway are set in sterling silver. Each measures 21 x 18 x 3 mm. This thulite pendant from Norway is set in sterling silver. It weighs 8.4 grams and measures 31 x 32 x 6 mm Topaz Mountain Juab County, Utah The third place Phillips recommends is located three hours southwest of Salt Lake City. It's a region where Utah Topaz has been mind for over a century, and is. 1 / 4. Found these near the trail at Black Diamond Mines (coal mine & silica sandstone mine) in Antioch, California a long time ago. They are actually from big blocks, just easily break. 441. 24 comments. Continue browsing in r/whatsthisrock. r/whatsthisrock. Dedicated to identifying mysterious rocks and minerals. 94.1k Septarian. Septarian Concretion or Septarians nodule were formed during the Cretaceous Period, around 50 to 70 million years ago. Sea levels were much higher then and the Gulf of Mexico reached inland to Southern Utah where many of the septarian nodules are found. Septarians are also found in Madagascar where conditions were similar